Turn Reddit into your competitive moat with Karmic →
Use Karmic's safe, scalable Reddit organic marketing guide for earning trust, ranking in search & answer engines, and driving measurable demand on the world's biggest community site.
by Colin James Belyea
Why listen to us?
I'm a former head of growth who spent years in paid media, helping startups acquire customers efficiently.
About 18 months ago, I was researching something on Google and realized I'd opened 30+ Reddit Threads in that single search session.
That's when it clicked. Something in the market was shifting, and I needed to figure out what and how to capitalize on it.
I've spent every day since then obsessed with Reddit. And I'm not exaggerating when I say it's the world's biggest untapped marketing opportunity right now.
So compelling, in fact, that I built an agency exclusively around it. This guide is the result of helping dozens of venture-backed startups crack Reddit Organic, where I will be sharing the exact playbook we use with them.
Here's what convinced me Reddit was worth the bet.
Who this Reddit Marketing Guide is for
This Reddit Organic marketing guide is for founders and marketing leaders in consumer service and B2B SaaS startups and scale-ups. If you're noticing that Reddit has inserted itself in your buyer's journeys over the last year or two, you'll want to read on.
Why marketers can’t afford to ignore Reddit
For years, Reddit was dismissed as a backwater social platform. That changed dramatically in 2023, and the momentum has only accelerated.
TL;DR
Reddit has quietly become one of the biggest and most influential platforms in the world, beating out legacy social in key markets and touching every stage of the funnel. It now dominates product research, shows up all over Google and AI answers, and is where your most serious buyers go to compare notes before they buy.
Reddit content now dominates Google Search and AI answers
Reddit’s new partnership with Google means Threads are reaching non-Redditors via Google Search, as well as it's being used to train Google's AI Overviews.
The result? Reddit is now the most-cited domain in AI search tools like Perplexity and ChatGPT. Your customers are reading Reddit Threads whether they're Redditors or not.
Reddit is now a top-tier social media platform
Reddit now drives more traffic than every social media platform except Facebook, including TikTok and Instagram. They hit 116M daily active users in Q3 2024 (51.6M in the US alone), up 19% year-over-year.
Revenue jumped 68% in the same period, proof that brands are already responding to Reddit's rise with serious investment.
Reddit drives product discovery and pre-purchase research
I’ll let the numbers tell the story.
Reddit is the #1 platform for finding "possible solutions to my needs or situation"
71% of people who discovered a brand (online or off) research it on Reddit before buying
74% of people agree that Reddit helps them make faster purchase decisions, ranking #1 vs. all social competitors
Translation: if your brand isn't part of the Reddit conversation, you're invisible during the most critical stages of the buyer journey.
Convinced? Great, me too. But let’s make sure we’re on the same page about what all this means before proceeding.
What is Reddit marketing?
Quick level-set for anyone new to the space (feel free to skip if you’re familiar).
Reddit marketing is the practice of earning attention, trust, and business results by participating in Reddit's communities (Subreddits) and leveraging Reddit’s ad platform.
Think of it as organic social + SEO + word-of-mouth, all happening in one place.
What Reddit Marketing can include:
Organic Brand Participation
Using a clear brand profile and showing up where your buyers already hang out. This includes answering questions and contributing to Threads posted by others and eventually posting your own Threads with varying degrees of self-promotion.
Reddit Ads
Use Reddit Ads to amplify your best content with interest, keyword, and Subreddit targeting, and building direct response ads to drive conversions or purchases.
Research & Social Listening
Mine threads for objections, language patterns, and feature requests. Feed those insights back into product, SEO, and creative.
Search/LLM leverage
High-quality Reddit answers rank on Google and get cited in AI overviews. Great posts keep working long after the Thread goes cold.
Community Management
Some brands eventually build their own Subreddit to house all relevant brand discussion, or start a topical Subreddit they can own and manage semi-publically.
What Reddit Organic can do for brands
There are a handful of very powerful ways that a strong organic Reddit presence can help brands scale up their brand awareness and customer acquisition.
If you follow our Karma Ladder process, you should unlock all four.
TL;DR
A disciplined Reddit presence lets you build durable market trust, dominate search and AI overviews, develop scalable free distribution, and actively shape how people talk about your brand. Done right, it can compound exponentially.
Build Scalable Market Trust
Reddit is a compounding trust-building platform.
Brands that show up transparently and consistently earn their spot in their niche’s most relevant conversations and communities.
Creating real value for your ICP with the content you create will help your brand become more known, liked, and trusted by the members of that Subreddit.
Maximize Search & Answer Engine Visibility
A strong Reddit presence creates a compounding visibility advantage across Google and AI-powered answer engines.
When you consistently contribute valuable content in relevant Subreddits, you're building two distinct but interconnected assets.
First, your own high-quality Comments & Threads start ranking in Google for the exact questions your customers are asking.
Second, as you build community trust, other Redditors begin organically mentioning and recommending your brand in Threads you've never even participated in (what we call "seeded mentions.") Both your direct contributions and these third-party endorsements create powerful momentum in search results.
The payoff can be substantial: you'll see more brand real estate in top-10 Google results and increased citations in AI-powered answer engines like ChatGPT and Perplexity.
High-quality Reddit content keeps working long after the original Thread goes quiet, potentially ranking for years and getting surfaced by AI tools trained on Reddit's data.
Create Scalable Distribution
Commenting with value triggers a positive feedback cycle we think of as a “Karma Loop”.
As you accumulate Karma and build credibility, Reddit's algorithm gives your content preferential treatment. Your posts rank higher, your Comments appear nearer the top of Threads, and moderators are more likely to recognize your helpful presence and leave your posts alone.
This earned authority lets you transition from Commenting on others' Threads to creating your own that sit at the center of industry conversations without worrying about content takedowns and shadowbans.
Over time, you’ll even be in a position to post Threads that are explicitly self-promotional (albeit occasionally).
Optimize Brand Sentiment
A high-karma Reddit account gives you the standing to actively shape how people talk about your brand across the platform.
When negative brand mentions or spam appear, your account will be better able to rank a strong rebuttal Comment closer to the top of the Thread, while being able to blunt the impact of negative Comments and help short-circuit any negative PR spiral.
How to tell if Reddit Organic the right investment for your brand
Not every brand should prioritize Reddit.
Before you commit time and resources, evaluate whether your business aligns with how Reddit users discover and research products.
We like to assess Product-Reddit-Fit through two lenses: Reddit Brand Analysis and Reddit Market Analysis.
Brand Reddit Analysis
Pre-Purchase Consideration
The more research your customers do before buying, the more likely they'll end up on Reddit.
High-consideration purchase journeys like SaaS tools, developer platforms, financial services, healthcare solutions, and broad-market B2B products naturally drive people to Reddit Threads for real user opinions and comparisons via their priority placement in search and answer engines.
Low-consideration impulse buys are much harder to win on Reddit since people don’t do their homework prior to buying.
Ask yourself: Do prospects search terms like "best [your product type]" before purchasing? If yes, investing in Reddit will help you influence this part of the buying journey.
Total Addressable Audience
Simply put, the more people who might buy from you, the better your chances of success on Reddit.
We're focused here on total people, not total market value. A $50M market with 10,000 potential buyers is very different from a $50M market with 5 million potential buyers.
If you sell telehealth, financial services, or freemium B2B SaaS, your TAA is likely in the millions and Reddit makes sense. If you're selling enterprise solutions with 50-person deal cycles or ultra-luxury goods, your TAA might be in the tens of thousands, and Reddit becomes much harder to justify.
Show vs. Tell Continuum
"Show" brands rely on visual appeal to sell. Think fashion, travel, food, lifestyle products. These brands thrive on Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube where imagery and video do the heavy lifting.
"Tell" brands need words to explain their value. Think consumer services and most B2B solutions, and any products solving specific pain points.
If a single photo can't capture what makes your product valuable, Reddit is likely a strong fit. If your product is primarily visual or aspirational, you'll be fighting uphill.
Reddit Brand Analysis
We also use a 10-point, decision-at-a-glance gauge of how well a brand can win on Reddit today.
We weight three things that actually drive outcomes.
SERP presence
How often do Reddit Threads already rank on Google’s first page for your priority non-brand terms?
Search "best [your category] ", "[your brand] vs [competitor]," or "[your category] worth it" and see what comes up.
If Google is already sending buyers to Reddit for your category, then you know there’s opportunity to tap into that traffic by contributing to and starting conversations in your space.
Lack of presence suggests Google doesn't see Reddit as the authoritative source for your category, limiting your long-term upside.
Industry Fit
How naturally does your category thrive in community Q&A format?
Consumer services & tech, gaming, fitness, education, and community-driven DTC brands typically score highest. These categories generate authentic peer-to-peer discussions where recommendations carry weight.
Enterprise software, niche offerings, and luxury goods tend to score lower. Conversations happen less frequently, users are more guarded, and the sales cycles don't map well to Reddit's culture.
Audience Alignment
What's the depth and quality of Subreddits where your real buyers actually spend time?
Look at size (Subscriber count), activity (posts per day), and relevance (how closely discussions map to your product). A category with 1 active, on-topic Subreddit where your ICP hangs out scores much higher than one with 10 tangentially related communities with low engagement.
This is independent of your current brand presence—we're evaluating whether the right conversations are already happening at scale, not whether you're part of them yet.
How to use it
Invest in Reddit (8-10 for Consumer, 7-10 for B2B)
Prioritize Reddit in your mix; pair organic advice with DPA/catalog ads)
Test with Guardrails (5-7 for Consumer, 5-6 for B2B)
Pilot in 2–3 priority subs; ship one meaty guide + daily helpful comments for 4 weeks)
Avoid for Now (0-4)
Monitor keywords/Subreddit growth; focus on SEO/LLM surfaces and reconsider later). Your sub-scores explain why you landed where you did and point directly to the first three actions to move the number next quarter.
Understanding Reddit’s Ecosystem
Unlike other platforms optimized for engagement or ad revenue, Reddit's architecture is fundamentally designed to protect community trust and filter out low-quality content.
This creates friction that makes Reddit difficult for brands, but it's also exactly why a brand’s Reddit footprint is so valuable once it’s been earned.
To succeed, brands need to understand how each layer of Reddit's system operates to reinforce & uphold community quality in order to work within those boundaries effectively.
Reddit’s Organizational Structure
Reddit's architecture is built on four layers, each designed to filter quality and protect community trust.
Users: Reputation as Currency
On Reddit, your account reputation determines everything. Every user starts at zero and must earn credibility through contributions the community finds valuable.
This reputation manifests as karma—the cumulative score of upvotes minus downvotes across every Comment and Thread you post.
Why this matters for brands: Reddit's algorithm uses karma to decide how visible your content should be. More karma gets your content more views and more engagement. You can't buy your way past this. You have to earn it.
Subreddits: Self-Governing Communities
The Reddit platform exists to facilitate thousands of mostly-independent communities called Subreddits.
Each Subreddit has their own culture, rules, and volunteer moderators who act as quality gatekeepers. Different posting formats, different tolerance for self-promotion, different expectations for how brands should engage.
Some communities welcome thoughtful brand participation, while others ban it entirely.
Moderators have absolute authority in their communities. They can remove posts, ban users, and set whatever rules they want. They're not Reddit employees, but passionate volunteers protecting the spaces they care about.
Why this matters for brands: There's no universal Reddit content strategy. Study each target Subreddit individually, understand its norms, follow its rules precisely, and build relationships with moderators before attempting any promotional content.
Threads: Where Conversations Happen
Threads are topic-specific conversations where Reddit users exchange ideas and experiences. Someone asks a question, shares news, or starts a discussion, hoping to engage the community into responding.
Reddit's algorithm heavily favors Threads that get early upvotes, creating a snowball effect for content the community deems valuable.
Why this matters for brands: Timing and topic selection are critical. Get it right, and a single Thread can generate hundreds of thousands of views and rank in Google for years.
Comments: Where all the value lives
Comments are where most brand trust-building happens. They're responses within Threads, the content that turns Threads into valuable conversations.
Reddit's algorithm rewards helpful, timely Comments with prominent placement. Having your Comments consistently upvoted build your karma and establish your authority in the community.
Why this matters for brands: Your Comment history IS your brand's reputation on Reddit. Months of helpful Comments create the trust that lets you eventually share promotional content without backlash.
How These Layers Work Together
Each piece of Reddit’s structure works together to keep community quality high by making it progressively harder to spam or manipulate the system.
Users must build karma over time through genuine contributions
Subreddits have moderators who remove low-quality content and ban bad actors
Threads only gain visibility if the community upvotes them
Comments from trusted accounts get better placement than those from new or low-karma accounts
This multi-layered defence system is why Reddit communities feel more authentic than other social platforms (and why Reddit content ranks so well in search results and AI answers).
Reddit Accounts & CQS
Behind the scenes, Reddit operates an invisible scoring system called Contributor Quality Score (CQS) that determines which content gets seen and which gets buried or removed.
It identifies which users are likely to contribute positively on Reddit, and suppresses the delivery of those that don't.
We estimate that two identical posts from different accounts can see 10x differences in views, engagement, and longevity based solely upon that account’s CQS score.
The Five CQS Tiers
Reddit assigns every account to one of five tiers, from highest to lowest. Your tier determines how moderators and Reddit's systems treat your content.
At the top, your posts will get preferential treatment. They'll appear higher in feeds, Comments get prominent placement, and moderators rarely flag content. These accounts face minimal restrictions and bypass many karma and age requirements that limit newer accounts.
Accounts on the lower end face heavy scrutiny. Posts get auto-removed or held in filter queues, Comments are hidden until manually approved by moderators, and face higher risk of permanent suspension.
What Influences Your Brand’s CQS
While Reddit hasn't disclosed the exact algorithm, we’ve identified these key factors:
1. Account Security
Verified accounts are treated as more legitimate from the start.
Must-dos:
Verify your email address immediately
Add phone number verification if possible
Enable two-factor authentication
Unverified accounts are automatically flagged as higher-risk and start with lower CQS.
2. Engagement Quality Over Quantity
CQS rewards authentic conversation more than mass posting, and Commenting appears to be one of the most effective ways to boost your score.
The pattern that works:
Post Comments more than Threads (aim for at least a 3:1 ratio)
Reply to others' Comments, not just the Thread itself
Engage in genuine discussions across multiple Threads
Respond to and occasionally send DMs
3. Content Performance Relative to Community Size
If you post to a large community (e.g., one with a million subscribers) and only get 5-10 upvotes, it will lower your CQS.
Better to post less frequently in communities where your content genuinely resonates than to spam large Subreddits with mediocre content.
4. Behavioral Patterns
Reddit monitors patterns that distinguish real users from spammers:
Positive signals:
Diverse participation across multiple Subreddits
Balanced mix of Threads & Comments
Consistent activity over time (not sporadic bursts)
Thoughtful, substantive Comments
Negative signals:
Cross-posting the same content aggressively
Frequent self-promotion without community contribution
Mass posting in short timeframes
Spam-like or one-word Comments
High rate of post removals or reports
5. Moderation Actions
Every removal, report, or ban impacts your CQS:
Major damage:
Post removals due to rule violations
Spam reports from users
Temporary or permanent subreddit bans
Marking account as NSFW (on new accounts, drops you to "Low")
Minor damage:
Deleting your own posts (signals you're hiding something)
Auto-moderator removals
Your CQS reflects your history across all of Reddit, not just individual Subreddits. One bad interaction can haunt your account platform-wide.
How brands should operate within the Reddit ecosystem
Now that you understand Reddit's structure and CQS system, it begs the question - how should brands actually operate on the platform?
Let's make this concrete with two scenarios:
Brand A: Low CQS
15-day-old account, 45 karma
Only posts in communities related to their product
Posts promotional content 3x per week
Comments are short and generic
Result: Low CQS score leads to Posts being auto-removed or held in filter queues. Comments are initially hidden. Moderators ban the account from key subreddits. After 60 days, the account is essentially useless.
Brand B: High CQS
90-day-old account, verified email and 2FA
550 karma earned through helpful comments across 6 communities
75%+ upvote ratio with consistent engagement
Posts promotional content 1x per month, helpful comments 3x per week
Result: High CQS score means posts reach the top of Subreddit feeds more often. Comments appear prominently in Threads. Moderators approve promotional content. After 60 days, the account is a trusted community voice that drives consistent traffic.
Build your CQS systematically and you'll have a Reddit presence that drives results long after other marketing channels have tapped out.
Understanding Reddit’s Ecosystem
Unlike other platforms optimized for engagement or ad revenue, Reddit's architecture is fundamentally designed to protect community trust and filter out low-quality content.
This creates friction that makes Reddit difficult for brands, but it's also exactly why a brand’s Reddit footprint is so valuable once it’s been earned.
To succeed, brands need to understand how each layer of Reddit's system operates to reinforce & uphold community quality in order to work within those boundaries effectively.
TL;DR
Reddit runs on invisible trust systems (like CQS), human moderators, and fiercely guarded community norms. To win here, you need to understand how accounts, Subreddits, and algorithms interact—or your content will quietly get throttled, removed, or shadowbanned.
Reddit’s Organizational Structure
Reddit's architecture is built on four layers, each designed to filter quality and protect community trust.
How to build a Reddit Organic program for your brand
Building an authentic presence on Reddit requires patience, strategy, and a fundamental shift in how most brands approach the platform. Many assume the answer is creating their own branded Subreddit, but we deliberately avoid this early on.
Instead, we recommend building credibility in communities you don't own first, then leveraging that authority to make owned communities work. This guide walks you through our proven four-phase approach to establishing your brand as a trusted member of your target communities.
Follow this Reddit organic marketing guide for 120 days and you'll bypass the spam filters that kill most brand accounts, earn credibility to influence conversations, and drive real business results without triggering the backlash that derails most corporate Reddit efforts.
TL;DR
The Karma Ladder is a four-phase system—Foundation, Authority, Engagement, Intent—that guides you from total unknown to trusted, revenue-driving presence in ~4–6 months. Each phase has clear goals, timelines, and rules so you never have to guess what to do next.
Phase 1: Lay the Foundation
Before you can participate meaningfully on Reddit, we’ll need to do two things in parallel - warm up our Reddit account, and build a strategy to reach the right people.
Building your foundation systematically signals to Reddit that you're an account in good standing, unlocking the freedom your account will need to operate across Subreddits and post types with relative impunity. By the time your strategy is locked in, you’ll be long past the restrictions that kill most brand accounts before they ever gain traction.
Goal
Establish account legitimacy so you can begin participating in target Subreddits without triggering Reddit’s spam filters or being flagged to moderators
Timeline
30 days minimum. Do not try to compress this phase as Reddit's algorithm specifically looks for accounts that rush through these steps
Targets
100+ karma
Verified email, 2FA enabled
Zero post removals or shadowbans
Account aged 30+ days
Account Warmup
Before doing anything, we need to build up a brand-affiliated Reddit account with enough credibility associated to allow us to start taking part in our niche’s important conversations. Here’s how to do it.
Day 1: Account Setup
Create your Reddit account with a brand + person name format (e.g., "Acme_Sarah")
Verify your email address immediately
Enable two-factor authentication
Add phone verification if available
Complete your profile:
Add your logo as avatar
Write a clear, concise bio explaining your value (no promotional language yet)
Add banner image (avoid text that gets cut off on mobile)
Include your website link in profile links section
Days 1-2: Browse Naturally
Read Reddit like a normal user to signal you're a real human
Click Threads, read Comments, scroll feeds
Join 5-10 Subreddits relevant to your interests (not the brand's interests—that comes later)
Spend 10-15 minutes daily browsing without Upvoting or Commenting yet
Days 3-7: Begin Light Engagement
Start upvoting Comments that you find genuinely helpful (5-10 per day max)
Gradually begin upvoting Threads (don't mass-upvote—this flags you as a bot)
Continue browsing naturally
Week 2: Start Commenting
Identify Low-Barrier Subreddits
Find beginner-friendly Subreddits where you can earn early Karma:
r/AskReddit
r/CasualConversation
Hobby Subreddits related to your interests
Pet-related Subreddits
Geographic subreddits (city/region where you're located)
Avoid your target brand-relevant communities during this phase.
Begin Commenting
Post 1-3 helpful Comments per day
Answer questions, share experiences, be genuinely helpful
Use a few sentences when you’re adding value, or a single one when you’re aiming to be witty or funny
Never mention your brand, industry, or expertise yet
Focus on earning upvotes through authentic contribution
Golden Rule: Comment on Threads that are 0-2 hours old for maximum visibility and karma potential.
Week 3-4: Expand Reddit Activity
Join Target Subreddits
Find and join Subreddits likely to contain your potential customers
Check in daily to lurk, read, and click-through a few Threads
Broaden Your Participation
Increase to 3-5 Comments per day across multiple Subreddits
Reply to others' Comments in both original Threads and sub-Comments
Experiment with posting 1-2 general Engagement Threads in beginner-friendly Subreddits (done right, these can earn far more Karma)
Engagement Thread Ideas
Simple questions that generate discussion, i.e.
"What's one thing you wish you knew when starting [topic]?"
"What's your unpopular opinion about [topic]?"
Monitor Your Progress
Use Karma as a proxy for CQS - it should be growing daily
Review any removed posts to understand why
Track which Subreddits and content types earn the most karma
Reddit Strategy
While building your account's karma, lay the groundwork that lets you hit the ground running once your account reaches 30 days old with 100+ karma.
Your Reddit strategy has two pillars: finding your market on Reddit, and producing Reddit content at scale.
Finding Your Potential Customers
There are two ways to surface relevant content on Reddit: Keywords and Subreddits.
Keywords
Brainstorm keywords that potential customers might use on Reddit. Think "phrase match" from Google Ads—specific enough to filter for the right people without being so narrow that nobody actually uses the phrase.
Keyword categories to include:
Product Categories
Product Features
Competitors
Your brand and product names (including all variants and common misspellings)
Customer Jobs-to-be-Done
Set up keyword alerts in Reddit Pro or another Reddit monitoring tool so you can check them daily.
Target Subreddits
Not all relevant Threads will surface through Keywords, so identify which Subreddits your potential customers hang out in and check them daily.
Search your keywords on Reddit to find active communities
Join them but don't post yet—observe the culture, read & record the rules
Note moderator activity level and tolerance for brand participation
Now we know where relevant conversations are happening, we can begin to set up our Comment production machine.
Content Production
Creating viral Threads requires creativity and individual attention. But scaling Comments can be systematized. The foundation is a Reddit-focused Brand Commenting GPT that takes a Thread URL and outputs a polished Comment in your brand voice, grounded in your materials and adapted to Reddit norms.
How it works
Copy/paste a Reddit Thread URL into your GPT. Have it analyze the Thread, evaluateswhat your brand can uniquely contribute, and draft a Comment tailored to that community. You edit before posting and refine your prompt over time as you learn what works.
Building your Reddit Brand Commenting GPT
Your prompt needs five sections, Brand Voice Guidelines, Reddit Copy Guidelines, Brand Response Calibration, Brand Reference Materials, and a Thread Analysis & Writing Workflow.
You can build one yourself, or you can just use the template we use with real clients.
Phase 2: Build Authority
Now that you've established legitimacy with Reddit's systems, it's time to build a presence within the Subreddits important to your target customers.
In this phase, you'll Comment on Threads relevant to your ideal customer profile. Every Comment builds brand presence, earns goodwill, and gives you real insight into what resonates.
Why this matters
Phase 1 got you past Reddit's spam filters. This phase gets you past human skepticism.
Authority Building is about becoming a recognized, trusted voice before you ever promote anything. You're earning the right to eventually share promotional content by proving repeatedly that you're here to help first. Let your Reddit handle do the advertising—curious users will find you. Push too hard and you'll trigger backlash that can destroy months of work.
Goals & Timeline
Target
How to Comment Effectively
Finding & selecting threads
Use keyword alerts to find relevant Threads within 0-4 hours of posting
Comment on 1-3 Threads daily across different communities
Focus on questions your ICP asks, misconceptions, solution comparisons, troubleshooting, and decision threads
Comment structure that works
Directly answer the question asked (including the unasked ones)
Add supporting context or reasoning
Optional: Next steps or resources (non-promotional)
Keep it scannable—use line breaks and bullets
Golden rules
Never mention your brand, product, or website
Never drop links to your website or content
If asked directly for recommendations, respond "Happy to share via DM"
Track & Improve
Review your Comments weekly
Which Subreddits earn the most upvotes?
Which topics resonate most?
What structures work best?
Are people following up with questions? (Good sign)
Any downvotes or negative reactions? (Learn why)
Double down on what works
Comment more in high-performing Subreddits
Lead with perspectives that earned strong upvotes
Adapt your tone to match each community
Build on successful frameworks
Beyond Comments: DMs & Research
As your authority grows, you'll get DM requests. You can mention your brand/product in private (ask permission before sharing links), but focus on offering genuine help even if they're not a fit.
Use this phase to gather intel for your organization:
What objections exist about your category?
How do customers describe their problems?
What solutions are they currently using?
What do they wish existed?
Feed these insights back to product, marketing, and sales.
Pitfalls to Avoid
Being too promotional too soon
Tanks credibility immediately
Solution: Stay patient—you’re building permission to promote later
Generic, AI-sounding comments
Redditors spot GPT slop instantly
Solution: Heavily edit AI drafts to sound human and specific
Not tracking what works
Wastes time on low-value activities
Solution: Review weekly and double down on what earns engagement
Ignoring negative feedback
Miss learning opportunities
Solution: Downvotes are data. Use them to adjust your approach
Commenting in only one Subreddit
Limits reach and creates risk
Solution: Diversify across 2–3 communities
Not engaging with replies
Misses visibility multiplier
Solution: Reply to responses—it signals authentic participation
Posting Threads too early
Jeopardizes your growing authority
Solution: Wait until Day 90+ when you have strong standing
Breaking Subreddit rules
Content removal damages standing significantly
Solution: Read rules before your first comment in each community
Taking interactions personally
Derails momentum
Solution: Occasional hostility is normal. Move on to the next Thread.
Done right, Engagement Threads reliably generate 5-6 figure view counts and rank quickly in search engines. This juices your account karma while signaling to moderators that your content drives community growth. You're now visibly curating important conversations in your niche.
Target
How to create Engagement Threads
Step 1: Map your market's hot-button topics
Keep a list of divisive ideas and emotional triggers your target customers care about. Search popular posts in your target Subreddits and reverse-engineer why they went viral. Look for patterns in topic, tone, and framing.
Step 2: Craft captivating hook & body copy
Title: Identify emotional trigger words and weave them in to improve click-through rate
Body: Set the stage, share your own relevant example, or agitate the central issue to spark discussion
Step 3: Post, monitor & compound engagement
Upvote and reply to strong Comments
Respond to Commenters to increase your Thread's Comment count to boost reach
Post 1-2 Engagement Threads weekly, rotating between priority Subreddits
Over time, triangulate around your best-performing topics
Why this builds your position
Accelerated karma & goodwill
Viral Threads juice your account karma and build substantial goodwill amongst the Subreddit’s active Members. This better positions you to attempt Direct Intent content later.
Moderator relationships
High-engagement Threads benefit the people running Subreddits. More engagement, more users, bigger community. Being the creator of that value helps immensely when you want to post self-promotional content or request an AMA, since your ability to do so will likely depend on moderators opinion of your brand.
Pitfalls to Avoid
Inserting yourself into the Thread
The temptation is real when your Thread hits 5-6 figures views. Resist it.
Self-promotion here severely limits your Thread's reach. Keep the Thread and your replies focused on the topic. At most, obliquely reference your experience in the space, but don’t go further than that.
Editing Threads to insert links later
Threads with links don't go viral very often so you might be tempted to add a link to a viral Thread after the fact. Again, resist the urge.
Edited Threads are often auto-flagged to moderators. They'll almost certainly see it and may remove your Thread, sanction your account, or shadow ban you entirely. The short-term gain isn't worth the risk.
Phase 4: Directing Intent
You've warmed up your account, built authority through Comments, and created viral Engagement Threads. Your name is now known, liked, and trusted in your space, and real demand is filling your pipeline.
You're ready to shift focus from your topic to your brand.
Directing Intent means creating content that ties your brand to the ideas you want to be known for, without triggering the backlash you've worked to avoid. This phase continues Authority Building and Engagement Threads while adding a promotional layer on top.
Target
Three Ways to Direct Intent
Ranked from lowest to highest risk/reward, here are the proven approaches:
Adapted Content
Repurpose existing assets like blog posts, founder LinkedIn posts, thought leadership for Reddit. Success depends entirely on creating discussion, so find the most controversial & captivating angle.
How to adapt content:
Pick ONE core idea, not the whole piece
Choose a single takeaway, story, lesson, mistake - whichever is most compelling
Ask: "If they remember one thing, what should it be?"
Rewrite the intro as a Thread title hook
Goal: stop the scroll
Use first person and specifics: "I wasted 6 months doing X…"
Hint at payoff: "Here's what I'd do differently next time."
Strip fluff and brand speak
Remove: brand references, feature lists, "our platform," formal sign-offs
Keep: stories, concrete examples, steps, frameworks
Aim for "useful notes to a friend," not "marketing asset"
Make it scannable
Short paragraphs (1-3 lines)
Use bullets and numbered lists
Bold only key words/phrases, not full sentences
Write like a human
First person, plenty of context
Conversational tone over "thought leadership"
Handle links carefully
Deliver full value in the Thread itself
Soft CTA only: "Full version here if you want it: [link]"
If links are frowned on in that Subreddit: "For the full version, Google '[Blog Post Name] [Brand] Blog'"
End with an engagement question
"What would you do differently?" / "Does this match your experience?"
Tailor to your audience (founders, devs, parents, etc.)
Brand Announcements
Share new feature launches, funding rounds, or partnership deals.
Most of the same rules apply to Brand Announcements as they do to Adapted Content. However, one option we have for Brand Announcements is simply posting a link to your announcement in a Subreddit that allows links & occasional self-promotion. Try both if you have the option to see which works better for you.
Critical: Since Brand Announcements are perceived as self-promotion, develop relationships with moderators in your top Subreddits and ask explicit permission before posting.
Founder or Leader AMAs (Ask Me Anything)
AMAs are powerful trust-building tools. Community members submit questions that your founder or representative answers publicly over the course of a particular day. When well-executed, they create evergreen content that ranks in brand searches indefinitely and demonstrates expertise to prospects.
AMA Best practices
Build community support first
Strong Subreddit history leads to better questions and more favorable sentiment
Commit to transparency
Answer honestly and even-handedly
Avoid spinning or dodging difficult questions
Limit frequency
No more than semi-annually to prevent oversaturation
Why AMAs work: Well-executed AMAs often rank highly in "[Brand Name] Reviews" searches and are often cited by LLMs when people ask them questions about brands that have hosted one.
Reddit Organic Attribution & Measurement
Every marketing campaign needs a clear measurement framework. Reddit is no different, but it requires more insight to get right.
Since Reddit best practices avoid directly trackable links, you must capture signals from multiple touchpoints. The Reddit funnel progresses from highly trackable/low intent to difficult to track/high intent. Pull these metrics weekly and monthly to understand each stage.
Reddit Metrics
Core data you can pull directly from your Reddit account:
Comments Posted: How often you engage in others' Threads
Threads Posted: How often you create your own Threads
Account Karma: Proxy for total value delivered to your target market
Post Views: Total views on your brand account’s Reddit Threads & Comments
Seeded Mentions: How many times other users mention your brand name on Reddit
Web Metrics
Limited direct attribution exists between Reddit and web analytics, but these serve as directional proxies for mid-funnel activity:
Reddit Referral Traffic: Website visitors who clicked through from your Reddit profile to your site
LLM Referral Traffic: Website visitors coming from AI platforms (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude)
While more complex tools can measure total LLM presence, tracking LLM click-through over time shows directionally how your Reddit presence influences LLM recommendations.
Qualitative Attribution
Reddit's influence (like most organic social) is often ephemeral and difficult to track with web tools. The only sure way to measure impact on leads or purchases is to ask directly.
Recommended approach:
Add a required "Where did you hear about us?" field to your lead form and purchase flow, with "Reddit" as an option.
Why this matters: Any hit to conversion rate from requiring this field will pay back 100x in accurate attribution data. Avoid optional fields or delaying asking, as doing so often distorts results beyond valid use.
Bonus Measurements
If you have time and budget, track these for deeper insights:
Reddit SOV (Share of Voice)
Your mentions vs. primary competitors' mentions
Reddit Sentiment
General sentiment around your brand over time
LLM Presence
Use tools like Profound to measure Reddit activity's impact on LLM recommendations
Pitfalls & Traps to Avoid
There's one way to make Reddit Organic work long-term, but hundreds of ways to screw it up. Here are the biggest.
Going Black-Hat
Black-hat Reddit tactics include buying upvotes, using shadow account networks, orchestrating fake grassroots campaigns (astroturfing), paying users to mention your products, and deploying bot networks. Short-term results can be impressive, as some brands have generated hundreds of thousands of views this way. But the risk profile has fundamentally changed.
The FTC & Reddit’s Crackdown
In fall 2024, the FTC's Fake Reviews and Testimonials ruling made most black-hat activities explicitly illegal at the federal level. Buying upvotes, paying for mentions, and orchestrating fake campaigns are now federal violations with serious penalties.
Reddit responded aggressively, dramatically increasing bot detection and fake engagement identification. The platform now actively hunts suspicious account networks and traces them to their sources.
When caught, Reddit doesn't just ban fake accounts. It deletes all their content and often bans the brands behind them entirely. Your entire investment disappears overnight.
Why It's a Bad Investment
Beyond legal and platform risks, black-hat tactics fail strategically:
Your investment can go to zero overnight. Improved detection means networks that worked for months can be wiped in a day, taking all content and distribution with it.
You don't control the accounts. Black-hat providers own the shadow accounts and infrastructure. If they get caught, their entire network goes down, often taking multiple clients with them since Reddit identifies connections between all accounts.
Consequences jump between clients. When Reddit uncovers a black-hat operation, they investigate the entire network. They ban all brands that used that provider, not just the accounts involved in one campaign.
The community never forgets. If caught, your brand suffers permanent reputation damage. Every future interaction gets scrutinized and your credibility destroyed.
The math is simple: Black-hat tactics offer temporary gains with permanent downside. Build the right way and you'll have distribution that compounds for years instead of exploding.
Linking & Self-Promotion Too Often or Too Soon
Mentioning your brand or dropping links before earning the right is the most common way brands tank their Reddit presence.
Why this kills your account:
Every mention of your brand or link to your website tanks your upvote rate. Posts that normally get 10-15 upvotes might get 2-3 with self-promotion. Comments that spark discussion get ignored or downvoted.
Lower upvote rates cascade:
Less karma accumulation – You're not building account reputation
Lower CQS – Reddit's algorithm suppresses future posts
Reduced reach – Comments appear lower in Threads, posts rank lower in feeds
Moderator scrutiny – Multiple promotional posts trigger attention and potential bans
This creates a downward spiral. Poor performance → lower CQS → less visibility → worse performance.
The one exception:
When users explicitly ask for tool recommendations, mention you can help but ask them to DM you. This respects community norms while capturing interested prospects.
Failing to Heed Reddit Warning Signs
Reddit gives you warning signs when your strategy is running afoul with platform of Subreddit rules. Ignore them and you'll lose your account. Respond appropriately and you can course-correct before permanent damage occurs.
Negative Responses & Aggressive Downvoting
If your comments are getting downvoted consistently or turning hostile, you've misread the room.
What this signals: Your tone doesn't match the community, you're being too promotional too soon, or the Dubreddit doesn't welcome brand participation.
How to respond: Delete downvoted comments immediately, step back and observe the community more carefully, adjust your approach to be more helpful and less promotional, and replace deleted comments with better ones in more receptive communities. Don't double down.
Comment/Thread Removal
When a moderator removes your content, it's a serious warning that you've violated community rules or norms.
What this signals: You broke a Subreddit rule (often self-promotion policies), your content doesn't fit community standards, or you're on the moderator's radar.
How to respond: Review Subreddit rules immediately, message the moderator politely to understand what went wrong, don't repost similar content in that Subreddit, and replace removed content by posting in more brand-friendly communities. Every removal damages your CQS.
Subreddit Bans
Getting banned means you've crossed a line through repeated rule violations, aggressive self-promotion, or moderator judgment that you're not adding value.
What this signals: You've lost that distribution channel permanently, other moderators may learn about the ban, and your strategy needs immediate adjustment.
How to respond: Accept the ban. Arguing rarely helps. Analyze what led to it, adjust your strategy for remaining communities, and focus efforts on subreddits where you're still welcome. Don't try to evade bans with new accounts as Reddit tracks this.
Account Shadowban
A shadowban means your posts and comments appear to you but are invisible to everyone else.
What this signals: Reddit's automated systems flagged your account as spam due to behavior patterns that triggered multiple red flags or site-wide policy violations.
How to respond: Check if you're shadowbanned at r/ShadowBan. If confirmed, stop all activity immediately, review what triggered it, and appeal through Reddit's official channels. If appeal fails, create a new account and avoid the behaviors that caused the ban.
The Pattern Matters
One warning sign is a data point. Multiple warning signs in quick succession mean your strategy is fundamentally flawed, and continuing will only make it worse.
Reddit rewards patience and genuine contribution. The warning signs are telling you to slow down, be more helpful, and earn your place in these communities before trying to extract value from them.
How to Scale Reddit Organic
Once you've built a strong foundation with a single account, there are three proven paths to scale your Reddit organic marketing presence: operating multiple brand-affiliated accounts, building owned subreddits, and distributing content at scale through Reddit Ads.
Each approach has different risk profiles and resource requirements. Choose based on your goals, budget, and risk tolerance.
More brand-affiliated accounts
The safest way to scale is running multiple brand-affiliated accounts simultaneously.
Why This Works
Scaling from a single account becomes increasingly risky. Moderators watch you more closely, competitors work to undermine you, and community members scrutinize your activity. If that account gets banned, you lose everything.
Multiple accounts distributes risk while letting you scale safely.
How to Execute
Use the same format: "BrandName_PersonName" (e.g., "Acme_Sarah," "Acme_Marcus").
Each account should:
Complete the full “Karma Ladder” process outlined above
Operate from separate devices/IPs to avoid connection
Build karma in different Subreddit combinations
Never interact with each other publicly
Differentiate by:
Expertise area (technical vs. strategic vs. troubleshooting)
Customer persona (enterprise vs. SMB, different verticals)
Content type (education vs. quick tips vs. engagement)
Subreddit territory (divide communities to avoid over-saturation)
What This Achieves
2-3x content output without concentrating risk, diverse voices that feel more human, protection if one account fails.
Critical Rules
Never operate multiple accounts from the same device/IP. Never have accounts interact with each other.
Building a Brand or Topical Subreddit
Owning your own community removes constraints and gives you complete promotional freedom as moderator.
Brand Subreddits
If customers already discuss your brand across Reddit, you're likely big enough to support your own community.
When to create one: Your brand gets mentioned regularly, you have 10,000+ customers, or you need a central hub for announcements and support.
Critical consideration: Brand Subreddits often become public support channels requiring dedicated staff. You'll need people to moderate discussions, post updates, and respond to complaints. A dormant or poorly-managed brand Subreddit hurts more than it helps.
For smaller brands: Skip this until you have thousands of active users already talking about you.
Topical Subreddits
Owning a subject-matter community relevant to your ICP is potentially the highest-ROI Reddit strategy available.
Instead of building a Subreddit about your brand, identify an underserved niche and create a topical community you own and grow. You become the authority while building a captive audience that doesn't realize you're behind it.
How to execute:
Identify gaps in Reddit's Subreddit ecosystem within your niche
Create the Subreddit using your established brand account (400+ karma, "High" CQS)
Seed 20-30 high-quality posts before inviting anyone
Invite your existing audience via email and social channels
Post consistently (daily or several times weekly)
Promote through Reddit Ads targeting adjacent subreddits
Growing it: The best approach is boosting organic posts via Reddit Ads to users in adjacent subreddits. Budget $500-2,000/month initially. As the community grows organically, reduce ad spend.
Distribute Content at Scale with Reddit Ads
After 4+ months of organic investment, you’ll understand what resonates with your audience. Combining this knowledge with Reddit’s ad product and you might just have an unfair advantage on your hands.
The Secret Weapon: Free Form Ads
Free Form Ads are promoted posts that look like organic Reddit Threads. Allocate 70-90% of your budget here.
You can apply everything you learned organically to paid distribution. Your best organic Threads become the inspiration for your ad creative.
Free-Form Ads Cost efficiency
With proper targeting and content, expect $0.10-$0.25 per engaged user in the US — 5-10x cheaper than Facebook or LinkedIn.
The Strategy
Don't focus on direct response for top-of-funnel. Reddit users don’t typically respond well to that. Instead:
Top of funnel: Free Form Ads get helpful content in front of your audience with the goal of identifying users who find the content useful or interesting
Bottom of funnel: Retarget engaged users with conversion-focused display ads
How to Execute
Identify your highest-performing organic Threads (or your competitors!)
Adapt for ads (slightly more promotional CTA is acceptable)
Target strategically using Subreddit & keyword targeting
Test 3-5 creative variations, double down on winners
Optimize for engagement first (lowers costs)
When to Start
Unless you need new customers now, wait until you have:
4-6 months of organic experience
10+ high-performing organic Threads
Clear understanding of what resonates
Attribution system in place
Choosing Your Scaling Path
Multiple accounts: Lower risk, higher manual effort. Best for consistent content production.
Owned subreddit: High effort to start, high long-term ROI. Best for strong existing communities.
Reddit Ads: Fastest scale, requires ongoing investment. Best with proven organic content.
Most successful brands eventually do all three.
Reddit Organic Marketing FAQ
Getting Started
How long does it take to see results from Reddit Organic?
Realistically, 4-6 months minimum. The first 30 days are spent building account legitimacy, the next 60 days building authority in your target communities, and months 4-6 are when you start creating high-engagement content and directing intent toward your brand. Reddit rewards patience, and brands that try to shortcut this timeline often get their accounts banned.
Do I need to disclose that I work for my brand?
Yes, absolutely. Reddit's culture values transparency, and many subreddits require affiliation disclosure. The good news: you don't need to hide it. Use a clear "BrandName_PersonName" username format and be upfront when asked. Your helpful contributions will speak louder than your affiliation.
Can I just hire someone to do this for me?
Technically yes, but be very careful. Many Reddit consultants still use black-hat methods (buying upvotes, shadow accounts, astroturfing) that violate FTC regulations and will get your account banned. Look for agencies that emphasize white-hat, long-term strategies and can show you their actual process. If they promise fast results (viral in 30 days!), run away.
How much time does this actually take?
Phase 1 (Days 1-30): 15-30 minutes daily browsing and Commenting Phase 2 (Days 31-90): 15-30 minutes daily for strategic Commenting Phase 3+: 15-30 minutes daily for strategic Commenting + Thread creation
You can systematize much of this with AI-assisted commenting workflows, but expect at least 5-10 hours per week for a single account done properly.
Strategy & Execution
What if my industry/product isn't on Reddit much?
Check your Reddit Analysis scores first (SERP presence, Industry Fit, Audience Alignment). If you score below 5, Reddit might not be worth the investment right now. However, underserved niches can be opportunities—consider creating a topical Subreddit to build the community yourself.
Should I create a brand subreddit?
Only if: (1) customers are already discussing your brand regularly across Reddit, (2) you have 10,000+ customers/users, and (3) you can dedicate staff to moderate it consistently. Brand subreddits often become public support channels—a dormant one hurts more than it helps. For most brands under $10M ARR, skip this and focus on participating in existing communities.
Can I post the same Comment in multiple subreddits?
No. Reddit's systems detect duplicate content and will flag you as spam. Each Subreddit has different culture, rules, and norms—your comments should be tailored to each community. Copy-pasting is a fast track to getting banned.
How many Subreddits should I focus on?
Start with 3-5 target subreddits in Phase 2. This gives you enough volume to learn what works without spreading yourself too thin. As you scale with multiple accounts, you can cover 10+ communities total.
What's the best time to post on Reddit?
Generally, early mornings (6-9am ET) and lunch hours (12-2pm ET) on weekdays work well for most Subreddits, but this varies by community. The key is posting when a Thread is 0-4 hours old—early Comments get preferential placement. Track your own performance to find optimal timing for your specific subreddits.
Technical & Account Issues
What's CQS and why does it matter?
Contributor Quality Score (CQS) is Reddit's invisible trust system that determines whether your content gets seen or buried. Reddit assigns every account to one of five tiers (Highest, High, Medium, Low, Lowest) based on account security, engagement quality, content performance, behavioral patterns, and moderation history. High CQS = your content appears higher in feeds and bypasses restrictions. Low CQS = your posts get auto-removed and comments hidden. You can check yours at r/WhatismyCQS.
My CQS just dropped to "Low"—what do I do?
Stop posting immediately. Take a 5-7 day break, then return with 2-3 weeks of commenting only (no thread creation). Review what triggered the drop—, looking for recent removals, spam reports, or promotional content. Don't delete old content or create a new account. Most accounts can recover if you adjust your strategy.
How do I know if I'm shadowbanned?
Post in r/ShadowBan and a bot will tell you within minutes. If shadowbanned, your Threads and Comments are invisible to everyone except you. This typically happens due to repeated spam behavior, suspicious patterns, or site-wide policy violations.
Can I use the same account for multiple brands?
Not recommended. Your Reddit account should represent one brand/person clearly. Switching between promoting different brands looks suspicious and will damage your credibility in all communities.
Should I use a personal account or brand account?
Brand account with the "BrandName_PersonName" format. This builds brand awareness while feeling more human than a corporate account. Pure personal accounts work for founders with strong personal brands, but most companies should use the hybrid approach.
Content & Commenting
Can I use AI (ChatGPT/Claude) to write my comments?
Yes, but you must heavily edit the output. Reddit users can spot "GPT slop" instantly—generic, overly formal, or salesy-sounding comments get downvoted and hurt your CQS. Use AI to draft, then rewrite to sound human, specific, and genuinely helpful. Include your brand voice, Reddit-specific language patterns, and authentic personality.
When can I start linking to my website?
Not until Phase 3 (Day 90+) at the earliest, and even then, sparingly. Most Subreddits frown on self-promotion. links to your site should only appear in genuinely valuable, non-promotional content (case studies, research, tools) maybe once per month maximum. For the first 90 days, never link to your brand.
What if someone asks for a direct recommendation in a Comment thread?
Respond with: "Happy to share via DM if helpful" rather than naming your product publicly. This respects community norms while capturing interested prospects. In DMs, you can mention your brand and share links freely.
How do I handle negative comments about my brand?
Respond thoughtfully and transparently without being defensive. Acknowledge the concern, provide context or your side of the story, and offer to help via DM if there's a specific issue. Your established credibility (high karma, helpful comment history) makes the community more receptive to your response. Never argue publicly or try to suppress negative feedback.
Can I delete Comments that get downvoted?
Yes, delete them quickly before they tank your karma and CQS further. But learn from them—why were they downvoted? Wrong tone? Too promotional? Misread the room? Adjust your approach and replace with better comments in more receptive communities.
Results & Measurement
How do I track ROI from Reddit Organic?
Track multiple signals: (1) Reddit metrics (karma, post views, seeded brand mentions), (2) Web metrics (Reddit referral traffic, LLM referral traffic), and (3) Qualitative attribution (add "Where did you hear about us?" with Reddit as an option to lead forms and purchase flows).
Reddit Organic is like any organic social. Much of its influence is hard to track directly, so survey attribution becomes critical.
What's a "seeded mention"?
When other Redditors organically mention or recommend your brand in threads you never participated in. This is the holy grail, as it means you've built enough trust and awareness that the community advocates for you without prompting. Track these by monitoring your brand name across Reddit.
How much traffic should I expect from Reddit?
Traffic is not the primary metric one should use to measure success on Reddit. We’re here to influence buyers toward your brand at the top of funnel, and convince them to go with you at the bottom.
The bigger value is often SEO/AEO impact and brand awareness that influences other channels.
Do Reddit posts actually rank in Google?
Yes. Reddit Threads increasingly dominate Google's first page for high-intent searches ("[category] best," "[brand] vs [competitor]," "[problem] solution"). Well-executed Reddit content can rank in Google for years and get cited in AI answers (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude). This compounds over time—your 6-month-old thread might still be driving traffic and brand awareness.
Risks & Pitfalls
What happens if my account gets banned?
Subreddit ban: You lose access to that community permanently. Adjust your strategy for other subreddits and learn from what went wrong.
Account ban: You lose the entire account and all karma/history. You can appeal, but if denied, you'll need to start over with a new account (ensuring you don't repeat the behaviors that caused the ban).
Domain ban: Worst case, Reddit flags your domain site-wide. Any links to your site get auto-removed across all of Reddit. This is rare but can happen with egregious black-hat tactics.
Is it risky to use Reddit Ads before building organic presence?
Yes. Most Reddit Ads failures stem from (1) poor creative that ignores platform culture, and (2) lack of attribution systems. After 4-6 months of organic work, you'll have proven creative and understand what resonates. Starting ads before this typically burns budget with poor results.
Can competitors sabotage my Reddit account?
Potentially, but it's harder than you'd think. Competitors could downvote your posts or report you to moderators, but Reddit's systems are sophisticated enough that a few malicious reports won't tank a healthy account. Focus on building strong CQS and following rules—this protects against both algorithmic and human attacks.
What if I accidentally break a Subreddit rule?
First offense: Usually just a removal with maybe a warning. Message the moderator politely to understand what went wrong, apologize, and ask how to avoid it in future. Don't repost similar content.
Repeat offences: Risk getting banned from that Subreddit. Every removal damages your CQS, so take rules seriously from day one.
Scaling
When should I create a second brand account?
After your first account reaches 400+ karma, "High" CQS, and 90+ days of age, and only if there’s more organic Threads you’d like to Comment on after you’re already Commenting 50+ times a month.
How many brand accounts can I run?
2-3 accounts is the sweet spot for growing brands. More than that becomes operationally complex and increases risk of accounts being connected by Reddit's systems. Each account should have distinct personality, expertise area, or customer focus.
Should I start with Reddit Organic or Reddit Ads?
Always organic first (unless you're in pure emergency mode). 4-6 months of organic work teaches you what resonates, builds proven creative for ads, and establishes attribution systems. Brands that jump straight to ads without organic foundation usually fail—wrong messaging, wrong targeting, no way to measure impact.
At what point should I hire help?
Either on day one, or when you’re having trouble keeping up. If you're spending 10+ hours weekly on Reddit and seeing positive ROI signals (karma growth, referral traffic, pipeline attribution), get help to scale.
When hiring, look for agencies that emphasize white-hat strategies, show you their process transparently, and have case studies proving long-term success (not quick wins that disappear).
Join the center of the world’s conversation
Start building your brand and acquiring customers on Reddit today.