r/Substack Breakdown

Volunteers run r/Substack, not Substack. Writers compare growth, earnings and Notes reach, and the year’s top threads are about AI.

Community-ownedCategory hubConsumer apps and media
By Karmic. Figures as of November 2026.

Executive summary

  1. It’s a writers’ room. Most posts are about growing subscribers, earning money and how Notes distributes posts.
  2. AI dominates the top threads. Substack training on writers’ work, AI detection tools and AI-written posts are the year’s biggest debates.
  3. Growth advice is everywhere. One of the most upvoted posts mocks courses about growing a Substack by teaching people to grow a Substack.
  4. Support questions go unanswered. Writers post about login codes, phone verification, hacked and suspended accounts, and support that doesn’t help.
  5. Substack isn’t here officially. No staff flairs appear, and a moderator says the mod team hasn’t been active in months.
  6. Karmic’s Take. Substack should win permission to answer in public, and it always has the option to build an official community for writers.

Who runs it

r/Substack was created in June 2019, and its longest serving moderator joined in 2021. Three more moderators joined in the summer of 2026. None are flaired as Substack staff.

In one of the year’s most upvoted threads, a moderator replied that the mods hadn’t been active in months, after a participant complained that AI-written posts with links to people’s Substacks were rarely removed.

Writers answer each other

Substack doesn’t reply with a staff or verified account. An account introducing itself as Linda from Substack posts feature announcements, such as a new Photography category, without a flair. Everything else is writers helping writers.

How much conversation each kind of post draws
Type of postPosted byTypical comments
AI debatesCommunity participantsAbout 70 to 380
Growth and earnings storiesCommunity participantsAbout 55 to 120
Opinions on where Substack is goingCommunity participantsAbout 50 to 90
Account and support problemsCommunity participantsAbout 5 to 60
Feature announcementsAn account introducing itself as SubstackA handful
  • Growth systems get shared. A musician laid out a 30 minute daily routine of comments and replies that brought 1,600 subscribers.
  • Skeptics push back. Replies call growth courses a pyramid and say Notes rewards spam.
  • Many write for themselves. A thread asking who writes for the love of it filled with people who never plan to paywall.
Exhibit 1
The growth-course loop, satirized
r/SubstackPosted by a community participantDiscussionMay 2026
I figured it out omg!

Jokes that the way to grow a Substack is to write about growing your subscriber count, then sell courses on growing subscriber counts, and that only a million people are already doing it.

248 upvotes55 comments
A community participant

Adds that people then post AI-written tips here with a link to their Substack at the end, and the mods rarely remove them.

A moderator

Says the mods haven’t been active in the sub in months.

A community participant

Calls it the MLM-ification of the online economy.

A community participant

Wonders about starting a throwaway Substack that spams motivational Notes, betting it would grow faster than their fiction.

One of the top posts of the year. A moderator confirms the moderators have been inactive. No Substack reply.

Recreated by Karmic from r/Substack as of November 2026. Posts from community participants are paraphrased and they are not named.

Subreddit rules for r/Substack

#What it asksType
1No self-promotionPromotion limits
2Ask for recommendations in the megathreadSupport routing
3Stay on topicQuality

A self-promotion ban that’s hard to enforce

The rules ban self-promotion and send recommendation requests to a megathread. A pinned post even says people using the subreddit to promote their Substack are doing it wrong. Comment sections fill with links to people’s publications, and participants say AI-written tip posts ending in a link stay up.

What do people post?

Day to day, people come to talk about growth.

What recent posts from community participants are
TypeShare
Growth, reach and earningsAbout 45%
Opinions on the platform and AIAbout 25%
Account and support problemsAbout 15%
Writing and encouragementAbout 15%
  • Notes reach. Writers ask why their Notes stopped reaching people and why growth stalled.
  • Earnings. People share what they make, and ask whether anyone earns $1,000 a month without writing about making money on Substack.
  • Accounts. Login codes, phone verification, a hacked account and a suspended account all come up, with complaints that support doesn’t help.
Exhibit 2
Just keep writing, and the pushback
r/SubstackPosted by a community participantAugust 2026
Just keep writing

Says the sub is full of complaints about subscribers and engagement, and the advice is to keep writing and let readers find you. Ran a blog with a million monthly readers ten years ago and is starting over.

120 upvotes23 comments
A community participant

Uses it as a public notebook and says hitting send helps their practice.

A community participant

Calls the advice a trap and says writers should review their numbers and study others in their niche.

A community participant

Says Substack is a social platform now and lays out a 30-minute daily routine of comments, replies and messages that brought 1,600 subscribers.

A community participant

Asks what to do about a suspended account.

Writers trade growth advice with each other. No Substack reply, including on the suspended account question.

Recreated by Karmic from r/Substack as of November 2026. Posts from community participants are paraphrased and they are not named.

General sentiment

r/Substack scores 46 out of 100 on Karmic’s sentiment score, which leans slightly negative.

To score it, Karmic reads recent posts and the top-level comments on the most active threads, and marks each one as positive, negative or neutral toward Substack. Questions count as neutral unless they complain or praise. A score of 50 means the positive and negative ones balance out. 100 would mean everything is positive, and 0 would mean everything is negative.

  • AI. The most upvoted post of the year accuses Substack of using writers’ work to train AI, and AI detection drew the most comments.
  • Where it’s heading. Some say Notes has turned Substack into another social network.
  • Support. Writers with locked or hacked accounts say they can’t get help.
  • Writing. Many say Substack got them writing again, and one says it helped them publish a first novel.

What people find about Substack on Google

This section covers what Google shows for four searches someone might run while evaluating Substack. As of November 2026, r/Substack appears for all four.

Where r/Substack shows up on Google
Searchr/Substack on page oneWhat else Google shows
substack redditYes, first, about 61K followers, with “Substack Is So Inauthentic”r/Blogging, r/SubStackGrowTogether, r/substackreads, r/rs_x and Slashdot
substack reviewsYes, “Anyone who’s been active on Substack, what are your…”Trustpilot 1.4, Product Hunt 3.8, Glassdoor, YouTube and writers’ own reviews on Substack
is substack worth itYes, “Is substack worth it to you as a writer or as a reader?”r/selfpublishing, Quora, Medium, YouTube and blogs
substack online publishing platform redditYes, eight r/Substack threads including “The hard truth about Substack”r/selfpublishing and r/Blogging
  • AI Overviews quote the community. For the publishing platform search, the AI Overview cites r/Substack to say earning a full-time income from scratch is hard and that Notes turned the platform into “Twitter-lite”.
  • Fees and support get summarized. For reviews, it lists the 10% cut, slow automated support and platform bloat.
  • Growth communities appear. It points to r/SubstackGrowthTips and r/Newsletters for promotion.
  • Other communities discuss it. r/selfpublishing, r/Blogging and r/Newsletters appear across the searches.

What Substack is doing well

  • People write because of it. Many say Substack got them writing again.
  • Growth is possible. Writers share real paths from zero to thousands of subscribers.
  • Ownership. Free to start, with writers keeping their email lists.
Karmic’s take

What Substack could be doing better

Colin James Belyea, co-founder of Karmic

r/Substack isn’t Substack’s, and by one moderator’s own account, the moderators haven’t been active in months. That’s an opening. The first move is to go to the mod team, offer help, and win permission to answer in public. The year’s most upvoted post accuses Substack of training AI on writers’ work, and the most commented thread is about AI detection. Those are the threads where Substack’s answer should be pinned at the top, so the next writer, and Google’s AI Overviews, which already quote this community, see Substack’s side. The login, verification and suspended account posts also tell me writers aren’t getting answers easily inside the product.

The second move is always open. Substack can build its own official community for writers. Its users already teach each other how to grow, and that’s exactly the kind of community a brand should own, with its best writers activated and its team in the comments.

Don’t just build a subreddit for your brand. Build community leverage instead.

Building a scalable and compounding Reddit presence starts with an owned subreddit that earns engagement and turns user-generated content into influence across the platform and beyond.

Community Leverage
One owned community · Reddit-wide influence · Amplified search and AI visibility

Context: Substack’s business

Background for readers who want the bigger picture behind the community.

  • Fees. Substack is free to start and takes 10% of paid subscription revenue, with card processing on top, as Google’s review summaries note.
  • AI training. Substack’s help center explains how writers can block AI companies from using their publication to train models, according to Substack support.
Other communities where Substack is discussed
CommunityWhat it covers
r/SubstackGrowthTipsGrowth tactics
r/SubStackGrowTogetherWriters swapping subscriptions
r/substackreadsSharing newsletters
r/NewslettersNewsletters across platforms

Planning a subreddit of your own? Karmic’s guide to building a brand subreddit walks through it step by step.

FAQ

Is r/Substack the official Substack subreddit?

No. It’s run by volunteer moderators, none flaired as Substack staff.

Does Substack post in r/Substack?

No staff or verified accounts were found as of November 2026. An account introducing itself as Linda from Substack posts feature announcements without a flair.

How active is r/Substack?

About 32,000 people visit each week, and the community gets about 601 posts and comments a week as of November 2026.

Can I promote my Substack in r/Substack?

No. Self-promotion is against the rules, and recommendation requests go in a megathread.

Sources

Explore similar Subreddits

Build your own Community Leverage.

Get Reddit insights delivered to your inbox.

Karmic Marketing Services Inc. ("Karmic") is an independent marketing agency. Karmic is not affiliated with, endorsed by, sponsored by, or in any way officially connected with Reddit, Inc. or any of its subsidiaries or affiliates. The name "Reddit" and all related names, marks, logos, and images are registered trademarks of Reddit, Inc. All references to "Reddit" on this website are made solely to describe the platform to which Karmic's services relate and do not imply any relationship, sponsorship, or endorsement by Reddit, Inc. Any third-party trademarks referenced on this site remain the property of their respective owners.

© 2026 Karmic Marketing Services Inc.

Build your own Community Leverage.

Get Reddit insights delivered to your inbox.

Karmic Marketing Services Inc. ("Karmic") is an independent marketing agency. Karmic is not affiliated with, endorsed by, sponsored by, or in any way officially connected with Reddit, Inc. or any of its subsidiaries or affiliates. The name "Reddit" and all related names, marks, logos, and images are registered trademarks of Reddit, Inc. All references to "Reddit" on this website are made solely to describe the platform to which Karmic's services relate and do not imply any relationship, sponsorship, or endorsement by Reddit, Inc. Any third-party trademarks referenced on this site remain the property of their respective owners.

© 2026 Karmic Marketing Services Inc.

Build your own Community Leverage.

Get Reddit insights delivered to your inbox.

Karmic Marketing Services Inc. ("Karmic") is an independent marketing agency. Karmic is not affiliated with, endorsed by, sponsored by, or in any way officially connected with Reddit, Inc. or any of its subsidiaries or affiliates. The name "Reddit" and all related names, marks, logos, and images are registered trademarks of Reddit, Inc. All references to "Reddit" on this website are made solely to describe the platform to which Karmic's services relate and do not imply any relationship, sponsorship, or endorsement by Reddit, Inc. Any third-party trademarks referenced on this site remain the property of their respective owners.

© 2026 Karmic Marketing Services Inc.